Fracking Citizen Journalists

Yesterday my neighbor Larry told me I had to see “Gasland” – and I’m embarrassed to say I didn’t know about it.

This is one of the major problems facing any activist- how do you get people to pay attention to your cause- or find your blog, or your video. It’s not as easy as “build it and they will come.”

From Wikipedia:

Gasland is an American documentary film written and directed by Josh Fox. The film focuses on communities in the United States impacted by natural gas drilling and, specifically, a stimulation method known as hydraulic fracturing.

via Gasland – Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Hydraulic Fracturing is also known as Fracking (which was also used as a substitute for the F word on Battlestar Gallactica version II) and is a process that injects water with a whole lot of chemicals into the ground- so the gas companies can get natural gas out of shale. Parts of Eastern Ohio are prime drilling areas. I haven’t the time to investigate if this extends into OH-3 and Highland and Clinton Counties (I’d appreciate some help on this).

This isn’t the only case of mistakes with drills (and I’m not even going to talk about the gulf oil spill) – locally, AK Steel is deep holing Ferrous Chloride up in Mercer County. Drill a hole, pump caustic hazardous industrial waste into the ground- and pray.

Some of the reviews I read of “Gasland” focused more on the film maker and his background in theater instead of what he presented. The industry tried to debunk his story claiming that Josh Fox “has been recognized by the “Fringe Festival” as part of the justification of their process. They even remind us that then Senator Obama voted for the law that created the “Halliburton Exemption.” The New York Times even questioned this law- last year, before the movie was out.

Here is the trailer for “Gasland”

Last Friday I wrote a post on the tools of Citizen Journalism– and included video cameras as an integral part of the toolkit. There has been quite a bit of heated discussion on what the “qualifications” are for “journalism” – and while Josh Fox may be biased against fracking- there are biases in all media- from Fox News, Rush Limbaugh, etc., to the New York Times.

I’ve been practicing this form of the fourth estate for the last four+ years on this site. I’m pretty proud of some of the stories I’ve broken, and how my investigations have connected the dots for others – including the Dayton Daily News.

We’ve just seen how a “music and culture” magazine- Rolling Stone, has brought down a four star general and his staff. Was it less of a story because of where it was published? Hardly.

Yes, seeing someone use a lighter to start a fire by turning on the water is sensational- because we’ve all grown up to think you use water to put out a fire. The Cuyahoga River in Cleveland caught fire in 1969 and made Cleveland a butt of jokes across the globe- but also set the stage for the “Clean Water Act” spearheaded by none other than President Nixon- who apparently did understand that without clean water, mankind is doomed.

I don’t have time to investigate if Mike Turner voted for the Halliburton exemption or if he received money from the natural gas industry or Halliburton- or Dick Cheney himself- but I’m sure one of my readers will do the research.

When it comes to energy policy- we’ve been talking about ending the dependence on foreign oil back to Nixon (as someone once posted a very funny link to a Daily Show segment). What we haven’t talked about is how we’re going to make sustainable living a cornerstone for building all of our energy policies. Walking to work and walkable communities is one effort that could have a huge impact on our economy as well as building a fiber network to make telecommuting a standard instead of the exception.

But, back to the whole citizen journalism slant to this story. No matter what your view of Mr. Fox’s award-winning film- fact or fiction, it has gotten people talking and asking questions- and sometimes, that’s all that matters.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed! If you wish to support this blog and independent journalism in Dayton, consider donating. All of the effort that goes into writing posts and creating videos comes directly out of my pocket, so any amount helps!

Leave a Reply

7 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
High WaterDavid EsratijstultsStephen G. EsratiGreg Hunter Recent comment authors
Notify of
Greg Hunter
Greg Hunter

I am familiar with Fracking!   If you want to go on FRACKING Trip head to the Allegheny National Forest. Home of Spindletop!  A FRACKING nightmare!  Close Well spacing and polluting ground water!  It ruins the groundwater as well as the surface but Energy was endowed by the Creator for use by man to destroy God’s Creation.  Free Will and all……  I of course love it as the Christians who were given Dominion have had more faith in Man than God.  Look no further than our own Representatives from the 3rd District.  Tony “Monsanto” Hall and Missile Boy Mikey think that man can solve all the problems that “God” did not get quite right….. OY VEY!  Here is a wonderful quote about the arrogance of man and his LUST for Energy.

And that’s the biggest ignorance; the biggest mistake: that the power of science was sufficient to generate endless energy and endless progress. That technology, by the hand of man, could break down the walls of Eden or steal fire from the gods. That human beings and societies could be carefully managed and controlled. That we could permeate our entire form of life with machines and yet retain a relationship of power over them, using them as means to our ends. That the earth could be made to pliantly yield itself as material for design and be made ready at hand, for any and all human desires, in the form of expendable energy.
Who are the arrogant ones here?

Greg Hunter
Greg Hunter

as building a fiber network to make telecommuting a standard instead of the exception.

How far out and how much ENERGY does this Fiber Network Use?  What is the EROEI?  Energy Returned on Energy Invested?  Me thinks you do not understand the connection between these blinking electrons and the lust for energy presented in GASLAND.  Utopia is everyone wired?  How much energy does the internet USE?


Could AK Steel be the reason why the state has banned swimming in Grand Lake St. Marys?
The water in this “lake” (actually a stump-filled reservoir for the Ohio-Erie Canal) has always been foul, but Celinans drink it.


From the tweeted article:

“People are used to living in caves in Afghanistan and building them schools is not going to change things,” Esrati said.
In a July 1 blog entry, Esrati confessed that this statement “wasn’t my finest.” But, he maintained his position concerning Afghanistan, citing his military experience as support for his contention.
Esrati wrote, “The reality is-my views on Afghanistan haven’t changed much since my days in Special Forces where the plight of the Kurds is the main case study. Afghanistan is a conjured-up country-that contains vastly different tribes who don’t like each other-where the main source of revenue is the drug trade.”

What a striking difference to the hack-job from DDN.  Rather than investigate something you say a little further (that commerce clause thing), the DDN just assumes you’re a crank.  These guys actually did some leg work and provided meaningful context.  My goodness, it’s almost like they are adding value by doing actually informative reporting.

High Water

Citizen journalism is one of the very few ways we can show people that most large corporations and most government officials do NOT have your best interests at heart.