The cheap bastards in Dayton City Hall
When I first got involved in my second career as an unpaid citizen of Dayton, I found our city to be overly bureaucratic. We had our neighborhood organization, that got things done- and then we had the mysterious “Priority Boards” which were a huge bureaucratic buffer zone between the neighborhood and the City Commission. They had offices, staffed with several full-time employees, who made pretty decent money. More money than the city commissioners who were part-time, and supposedly the brain trust that was steering our city to prosperity.
When I, or anyone else would go to the City Commission with a complaint, they’d say “have you been to your priority board about this?” As if it was a crime to actually talk to and expect action from those we elect.
The city patted itself on the back often for being such a model of “citizen participation”- when in fact, it was just another place to hire people into patronage jobs. It really didn’t require any skill to work for the priority boards- it was all about who you knew.
So, each neighborhood had to have its own organization- a neighborhood association, which ideally was a non-profit (a 501 c-3 by the tax code), and had to hold elections to have at minimum a leader, a treasurer and a recording secretary, and then, depending on the size of your neighborhood elected representatives to your priority board seats- which could be anywhere from 1 to 4 in our case. The problem was that the neighborhoods, planning districts and precincts didn’t follow any of the same boundaries- making for coordinating the many heads more like a Hydra than a true democratic process.
At one point, to make sure the neighborhoods had a say- additional seats were created per organization, be it a full fledged neighborhood association or even a block club. Throw out proportional representation- just try to fill the rooms- to keep the patronage pogues looking busy.
The system was expensive- with offices in the seven “districts” of the city. Southeast held about 40% of the population- and always seemed to have the most “representation.” The downtown priority board was an afterthought- and didn’t even have a full-time staffer. The historic districts were split between all the priority boards- when in fact- they, along with downtown, were the ones who were most alike- and could have had a really strong voice if they hadn’t been segregated.
While the city was still flush with cash- thanks to corporate headquarters like Reynolds & Reynolds, Mead, Standard Register, NCR- it was easy to blow money on the priority board patronage jobs- which could be counted on around election time to help the Democratic Party have an Army to make sure their chosen candidates got elected. All was good and fine…
Until, well, the system broke and a Republican managed to get elected Mayor. Mike Turner, managed to tick off Reynolds & Reynolds CEO David Holmes- getting Holmes to put a ton of money behind Tony Capizzi to challenge Turner- and when Turner won again- Holmes took his company to Kettering.
There were other things at play, some pre-Turner, with Tom Danis buying off Police Chief Tyree Broomfield to step down, games played with an “Architectural review committee” slowing down the city-funded Arcade tower project- so Danis could get his Cit/Fed tower built first- and who knows what the Beerman family was doing to keep their real estate deals going- where they were making a fortune off the construction of 675, and CJ McLin and his daughter Rhine were doing the same with the 35 West deal.
The priority board system was a way to make the poor citizens of Dayton think they mattered, when in fact, they were just there to keep the party in power so that the friends and family of the Monarchy of Montgomery County could continue to kiss the wealthy asses of those who really were supporting our city.
I’d advocated for getting rid of the priority boards from day one- to have neighborhood presidents meet directly with the city manager 4 times a year. Note- the city manager- not the mayor or the commission, they aren’t supposed to be the ones running our city, but we’ve long forgotten that.
So, in today’s paper, we find out that what’s left of the vaulted citizen participation system is about $96K a year thrown out to the paupers to play pretend with- compared to a budget that used to run close to $8 million a year:
The city provided about $13,000 for 27 neighborhood festivals this year.
The city also awarded $83,046 in mini-grants to 20 neighborhood projects this year, three times the amount in 2014.
Source: Dayton pushes policy reforms
I always found it odd, that 25 years ago- our neighborhood thought it was a privilege to get to ride around on the back of a trash truck once a month on a Saturday morning to pick up the garbage that our overpaid trash collectors skipped.
People in other communities would wonder why would you pay your taxes to spend your Saturdays doing “community service” without a court order.
This is the travesty of Dayton. While the people who are still here fighting to make their community a nice place to live, and paying the 2nd highest income tax in the county, the cheap bastards in city hall are bragging about “awarding back less than $100,000 a year” to help those who volunteer- while giving multi-million-dollar tax breaks to General Electric, while raising trash and street light fees, and still having no problem buying buildings for half a million each- for which there is no public use.
Yeah. “Cheap bastards” is actually a nice name, for people who are really taking a crap on the people they represent. And, one other thing, you shouldn’t have to work so hard to have a great, safe, clean neighborhood. You should be able to spend your time living your life.
David, you have earned my respect for fighting the sheer incompetence that is Dayton City Hall for so long – and for willing to dig in and stand up for what you believe in, despite getting screwed again and again.
It took me far less to throw in the towel and vote with my feet: the streetlights, the taxes, and the kangaroo election last year of Democrat versus Democrat for the mayor’s office.
Inshallah, I’m moving to Beavercreek in the next month – where I’ll enjoy a lower tax rate (both property and income), a safer neighborhood, a better school district, and a more responsive City Hall.
I won’t miss being a financial victim of Dayton’s continued self destruction at the hands of its politicians. I’ll still read this website – and I’m sure I’ll hear on Channel 7 about the latest shooting or scandal – but I’ll do do safely out of reach of the city.
Sadly, it’s made me a permanent opponent of Dayton regionalism. While I support it in theory, it’ll be a cold day in hell before I ever let Nan get any more power than she currently has.
Good riddance to that broken down BS system. This is a one party town with no need to continue to buy off voters – they all vote for “the Democrat” – Nanny Whale. Now enjoy what you’ve brought on yourselves my fellow citizens.
I did not vote for any taxes nor am I going to pay for something I did not vote on but forced on me. You all should do the same.
Time for all residents to stop paying taxes and have a party to celebrate it.
This will stop all services however, police fire, and infrastructure. The private sector can take over republican, democrat, or otherwise will not matter all citizens need to come together to stop their paychecks and we can take over for pennies on the dollar and have huge surplus in the budget. There will be no power hungry elected officials seating for our official elected representatives that will make zero dollars for their dead seat they sit in. At that point they can sit and spin and tell us how wonderful their selected title really resides for themselves.
At that point Dayton can begin to thrive as their will be no costs or red tape for a business to move to Dayton. This of course will invite citizens to move into the city in record numbers as there will be no impediment to move here.
This is just a dream and lets hope it can be reality one day.