Esrati on Unions

This is my position on unions and for a Democrat, it may be akin to political suicide if you believe the system isn’t broken.

Today’s Dayton Daily News had a small item saying “Union rolls see biggest jump since 1983” that stated that union membership in the US is now 15.7 million, or 12.1% of the workforce. The distribution is interesting in that only 7.5% of private sector workers are unionized and 35.9% are public sector.

In the Montgomery County Democratic Party, I’ve been told that 50% of the screening committee is union, down from 75%. This may explain why Jane Mitakides got the endorsement instead of me.

My father was a Newspaper Guild steward. I walked the picket lines with them when I was a kid. My father will tell you a story of how I went as a “spy” to see when the Teamsters were coming to either cross the line, or to stop when I was about 10, but that’s another matter.

I believe unions are good. I believe in the right to collective bargaining. I believe unions are there to protect workers rights, to demand safe and fair working conditions. I think Wal-Mart would be a better company if it was unionized, as would many of our “big box retailers” which seem to think of labor as a commodity, when in fact, it is what makes the ultimate difference in performance- much more than the C-level suite.

However, here are my problems with unions today:

  • I don’t believe unions dues should be used for political purposes. An extreme example: many unions have ardent pro-lifers in their membership. Unions tend to support Democratic candidates who are often pro-choice. This is patently unfair.
  • I don’t believe in tenure based on seniority, or tenure in general. As a small businessman, I am judged everyday by my performance. Just like a college basketball team. Just because I’m a senior, shouldn’t guarantee me playing time, I still have to earn my spot. I believe that experience is a valuable business asset, and that companies that want to get rid of senior people for any reason other than performance, are exercising poor business judgment. Performance expectations and ratings guidelines should be an integral part of any labor contract, if there is a question of performance, it should be clear by evaluation of well kept records if an employee was unfairly terminated.
    Side note: If we have universal health care, one of the major reasons for laying off seniors (with higher health care burdens) will be eliminated.
  • I believe unions have been quiet on a major issue, only coming forward lately in negotiations: executive pay and perks. I have no problem with founders of a company making billions. However, this new class of carpet-bagger CEO, who can come in for a year or two and steal multi-millions from a company while “right-sizing” it for short term stock performance and their cash-out must stop. If a company wants to pay CEO’s exorbitant salaries, they must either go private, or be held to some sort of reward linked to risk- for the entire company. Companies are team sport- not golf. We need to put an emphasis on team play into CEO pay.

With that all said, the political system hasn’t changed, and endorsements from unions and organizations (by majority vote, in a public meeting) do make a difference in campaigns. I will not accept money from Unions, Special Interest Groups or Corporations, but would appreciate any union brave enough to support my campaign.

The current system has become, as John Edwards said, more of an auction than an election. I want to represent the free thinkers, the next generation of workers and the concept of the individuals independent rights that this country was founded on. So, if you can get a majority of members in your organization to endorse me, I would be grateful.

Individual donations will be gladly accepted. If you agree with this idea, please consider donating as much as you can afford. We won’t see a change, until we prove that elections aren’t for sale to any group other than hard-working Americans.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed! If you wish to support this blog and independent journalism in Dayton, consider donating. All of the effort that goes into writing posts and creating videos comes directly out of my pocket, so any amount helps!

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Esrati on Unions"

Notify of
gene II

David you re awful quick to rag on Wal-mart but yet you shop at Sams Club…..

David Esrati
David Esrati

If I could shop at Costco without having to use 8 gallons of gas, I would.
We all have to compromise some.
But, this argument is as lame as the one the neo-cons make about Al Gore’s carbon footprint in traveling the planet to stop Global warming.
Are all people named Gene rejects from the gene pool?


From…. “Only about 13 percent of Costco’s 103,000 workers are unionized, but the relative labor peace is symbolic of the company’s relations with employees.”

Is it the fact that even some of CostCo’s employees are unionized that makes CostCo OK? Unions have tried to organize at many local WalMarts and, by and large, the WORKERS have rejected their efforts. I’ve read, in the mainstream press, about union organizers going into WalMarts wearing red vests with “How Can I Help You….unionize?” on the back, clearly in an effort to confuse customers. What kind of crap is that? That kind of behavior is part of what’s contributed to the downfall of unions.

Also, these union workers show very little pride in their employers. You can go all over Dayton and see people wearing t-shirts and jackets with “Proud Member of Local 987656 of the Whatever Union”, but nothing about “Proud to be employed by the company that actually writes my paycheck.

So, David, what if you were required to hire only union graphic artists? You’d be required to pay them a certain amount – maybe even more than they were truly worth to you? Is that fair – having some organization tell you how to treat your employees and what to pay them? No, it’s not, and you wouldn’t stand for it!

If you want to rag on WalMart, go ahead! But forget about the unions that their employees don’t want. Instead, focus on WalMart’s huge abuses of eminent domain laws in order to procure desirable properties.

And speaking of OwlGore and his carbon footprint…What about his lame display of taking public transportation to get to the award ceremony in order to conserve fuel, but his luggage still took a private Mercedes SUV? That guy is a joke! Even the Europeans were laughing at him for that one!

Muchos Gracis, David, for giving us this forum to pick on you! :) Great seeing you the other night.


gene II

Well Mr. Esrati you are within walking distance of Krogers… try again………it s not about gas….it s about what the rest of society feels price (which if you re whining about the cost of gas price seems indeed price is an issue) and convenience …….so let the double talk cease please it s NOT winning you any votes. Say what you mean and mean what you say!