Categories

Why you shouldn’t vote until election day in Dayton

David Esrati |

October 26, 2025, 06:53 PM |

Tomorrow, Tuesday, Oct 7, 2025 early voting starts. But, what’s already started is the dirty tricks squads- and even on the last day, you could find out something about a candidate that may make you regret voting for them. It’s happened to me before.

There are still candidates forums, events, interviews and most importantly, the mailers you are about to start getting attack ads, like the one I just got with Jeff Mims attacking his opponent for Dayton Mayor- Shenise Turner-Sloss. (Full disclosure- I do work for the challengers- in this race, Turner-Sloss, Darryl Fairchild and Jacob Davis).

Last time, when Shenise and Darryl were running, the party sent out attack mailings that were unsigned- and absolutely dirty.

This time, Jeff is just desperate. As if he’s delivered anything except your tax dollars to developers.

Considering Mims hired Gen Murphy who doesn’t have a nice bone in her body, and probably commissioned this push poll this summer, you can expect a whole bunch more. For those of you who don’t know what a push poll is- it’s a fake poll, with biased nasty questions. We did a screen recording of it for you:

But wait, there’s more.

During the NAACP candidates forum intermission, Mim’s running mates Darius Beckham and Karen Wick had a little chat in front of a hot mic. It will tell you exactly what they think of the voters they want to represent.

Over the next 30 days all kinds of things could happen. If you vote early, you might not be fully informed.

You may see a side of a candidate you never saw before.

The FBI could always come in and tell us that they are going to do another round of indictments in “Operation Demolished Integrity” where they only charge Black people.

And, the most important deadline to learn everything you need to about the candidates is the Pre-General campaign finance reports due Oct. 23, 2025 to disclose activity through Oct. 15, 2025 This is where you find out who has bought and who has sold out.

Need some good examples?

How about when Kitt Cooper donated $10K to Rhine McLin and $5K to Nan Whaley? What? You don’t know who he was or why? Read about it here: Money may not buy happiness, but it might buy a politician And know this, Nan is calling donors to raise money for Jeff Mims, Darius Beckham (who she helped raise in the Friends and Family Program before handing him over to Jeff Mims) and Karen Wick.

As it is, the amount of money Wick and Beckham raised in the primary is insane: The high cost of keeping Dayton’s Culture of Corruption in power

But what’s more interesting is in a city where most residents have a hard time giving $100 to a candidate, the number of people who gave $250 or more to them. Who they are, where they live are really relevant. Here’s just the big money backers of Wick and Beckham (and ostensibly the Mayor. This is just the list of donors who gave to both, in excess of $250 (which should leave out family friends- etc).

50 people, $73,600

NameAddressAmount
Charles Carroll3770 Terrace Creek Way Bellbrook OH 453056000
Barbara Mills2037 Beaver Valley Road Beavercreek OH 454345000
Martin Foster126 Jackson St Dayton OH 454025000
Larry Dillin15N460 Prairie Hill Circle Pine Grove IL 601405000
William Pflaum114 Menlo Park CA 940254000
Kimra Van Vickie620 Treaty Way Greenville OH 453312000
Vail Miller3840 Stonebridge Rd Kettering OH 454192000
Beverly Shillito40 N Main St Ste 1900 Dayton OH 454232000
Charles Schroeder4850 Tait Rd Dayton OH 454292000
Thomas Becker648 Murrell Dr Kettering OH 454292000
Clinton Coble1336 Woodman Dayton OH 454322000
Michelle Mathile249 Park Rd Oakwood OH 454192000
Devon ValenciaRidgeway Rd Oakwood OH 454192000
Firefighters Local 136 PAC145 Warren St Dayton OH 454022000
Maureen LynchLimestone St. Yellow Springs OH 453872000
Frost Brown Todd LLP PAC301 East Fourth St, Suite 3300 Cincinnati OH 452022000
George Oberer2014 Hickory Knoll Dr Xenia OH 453852000
Greg Thompson4197 Research B Dayton OH 454302000
Marie Miller620 Treaty Way Greenville OH 453312000
Malte VonMatthiessen1234 Livermore St Yellow Springs OH 453871500
Mark Brueninghaus2977 Far Hills Av Dayton OH 454191000
Michael Riordan1421 Woodstock Dr Oakwood OH 454191000
Jenell Ross2398 Briggs Rd Dayton OH 454591000
Bear MonitaWoods Ct Kettering OH 454291000
Carl Johnson3796 Seiber Ave Dayton OH 454051000
Richard Stover100 W Monument Ave Dayton OH 454021000
Beth WhelleyGatekeeper Dayton OH 454581000
Susan Blasik-Miller116 Peach Orch, Oakwood OH 454191000
Steven Johnson1010 Runnymede Rd Dayton OH 454191000
Tom Archdeacon105 Jones St Dayton OH 45410600
Sharen Swartz Neuhardt4625 US Route 68 N Yellow Springs OH 45387500
Silvia Anderson2264 Annandale Pl Dayton OH 45385500
Joann Ringer633 East Schantz Ave Dayton OH 45409500
Steven Budd1821 Ruskin Rd Dayton OH 45406500
Christopher Shafer72 Stanton Dr Springboro OH 45066500
Carl Struever327 Warren Ave Apt 3H Baltimore MD 21230500
Ronald Mellon6480 Wengerlawn Rd Brookville OH 45309500
Michael Wagner6689 Crossbrook Dr Dayton OH 45459500
Regina Holman2538 Bridgeport Dr Dayton OH 45406500
Nan Whaley217 Wroe Ave Dayton OH 45406500
David Dickerson9349 Waterston, Cincinnati OH 45249500
Kathleen Harper438 Orchard Dr Oakwood OH 45419500
Michael McGovern1715 East 4th St Dayton OH 45403500
Flanagan Lieberman & Rambo10 N Ludlow St #200 Dayton OH 45402500
Matthew Joseph1338 Ashland Avenue Dayton OH 45420500
Jason Woodard505 S Jefferson St Dayton OH 45402500
Lisa Gossett18120 Dog Leg Rd Marysville OH 43040500
Kurt Stanic3887 Arcadia Circle Willoughby OH 44094500
brent johnson6 Stonemill Rd Dayton OH 45409500
total73600

And remember folks, that was from a report a LONG time ago. Who else has bought in?

Since I’d planned on posting this earlier, I didn’t have the pre-primary numbers, but now I do. Neither Mims or Turner-Sloss filed complete reports that I can find online. Mim’s raised $141,399 and spent a bunch, $122,432, but we don’t know anything else.

  • Wick brought in another whopping $53,445
  • Beckham another $41,445
  • Fairchild $36,472
  • Davis $11,021

Those are some insane numbers. What’s crazier is where they spent it. Gen Murphy is hauling in $1500 a month from both Beckham and Wick. This is a “company” that doesn’t have a website and uses BATTLEAXE DIGITAL out of Beverly Hills for “Digital Advertising.” Local folks aren’t good enough.

Now, before you go saying this is sour milk, let’s look at Fairchild and Davis using someone named “Blue Pear” out of Iowa City Iowa to do consulting and mailers. On the front page of this fruits site, is my work.

Yep, I took the pics, wrote the copy, designed that mailer in 2021 for Shenise and Darryl.

I guess buying what Dayton builds isn’t important to any of these candidates or the integrity of their vendors.

There are also the candidate events which are sparsely attended. I went to the Belmont Eastmont Hearthstone candidates event last week, and asked a question for the Mayoral Candidates. Mim’s started talking about 25 years ago and didn’t even know the name of the last outdoor Dayton pool he filled in (Fairview- he say’s Mallory). Watch.

I’m not impressed by either candidate’s answer. According to the Director of Parks and Rec via a recent email exchange, “At this time, we do not have a need for seasonal lifeguards.” Note, they have 3 guards “working” at all times, 1 in the chair for a 20 minute shift, and 2 back in the break room screwing off.

Marcellus claims the issue is a lack of “I’m referring to our permanent positions — these are the roles essential for keeping our pools operational…. responsible for maintaining pool chemicals or operating the pool’s mechanical systems”

His pool director, Marina Storek, claims they are short $25K a year for pool chemicals to open up the Roosevelt splash park which has been closed since Covid. If the city needs pool chemistry/maintenance and can’t find the people- do what hotels and rich people do, put it out to bid and hire a maintenance firm. But, really, it doesn’t take more than 1 person to manage 3 pools chemistry and maintenance.

btw- Kettering has it’s splash park in the summer- with close to 20 guards working at a time. Dayton pay’s at least $3 more an hour for guards than anywhere else- but hires them through a temp firm, costing them additional money. As I say- Bad Management.

Later, when Commissioner Fairchild was presenting, he was rudely interrupted by Commissioner Joseph who was sitting in the gallery. I’d call it combative to say the least. Maybe I’ll get that video cut soon and post it too (this takes time)

But, this isn’t just about making decisions on who to vote for, it’s about being the best most informed voter there is.

And while I’ve concentrated on Dayton’s race, there are other dirty tricks out there too.

The Montgomery County Republican Party sent out this lovely piece of hate mail calling Sam Dorf a Marxist
The Montgomery County Republican Party mailed this about Sam Dorf in Oakwood

We should expect better from politicians, from the parties, for our leaders. If you early vote, you may not have all the information you need. But, the most important thing is to be like the mailman on election day: “Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night stays these couriers from the swift completion of their appointed rounds”

Your mission is to vote, and to get all your friends and neighbors to vote, and to be informed.

I’ll be releasing my endorsements before next weekend.

If you enjoyed reading true breaking news, instead of broken news from the major media in Dayton, make sure you subscribe to this site for an email every time I post. If you wish to support this blog and independent journalism in Dayton, consider donating. All of the effort that goes into writing posts and creating videos comes directly out of my pocket, so any amount helps! Please also subscribe to the Youtube channel for notifications of every video we launch – including the livestreams.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

13 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Melissa

Regarding the nasty red-baiting lit sent out this election cycle to harm Democrat music teacher Sam Dorf, this was asked and denied in local news.
https://www.daytondailynews.com/local/election-2025-3-candidates-in-race-for-2-oakwood-council-seats/KOAJ26WIL5BVZISYDPLHJL7CQ4/

My prime suspect in this debased activity is lifelong Republican Leigh Turben (77). Her hubby Dan Turben (83) is also a REP. Did Leigh Turben really get behind this evilness or did local Republican Party Chair Phil Plummer whisper in her ear like the Devil?

Now, it COULD be the UNClassified gardener coaxed by her UNClassified hubby (both were former registered Republicans). I don’t know. Here’s the meat and potatoes of Republican Leigh Turben’s public voting record – you decide.
Year of Birth: 1948
Party: REP
Precinct: 2820 – OAKWOOD C
Voting History (up to county’s last 40 elections):
Voted:X – 05/06/2025 Primary/Special Election
Voted:x – 11/05/2024 General Election
Voted:R – 03/19/2024 Primary Election
Voted:X – 11/07/2023 General Election
Voted:X – 08/08/2023 Special Election
Voted:x – 11/08/2022 General Election
Voted:R – 08/02/2022 Primary Election
Voted:X – 11/02/2021 General Election
Voted:x – 11/03/2020 General Election
Voted:r – 04/28/2020 Primary Election
Voted:X – 11/05/2019 General Election
Voted:X – 05/07/2019 Primary/Special Election
Voted:X – 11/06/2018 General Election
Voted:R – 05/08/2018 Primary Election
Voted:X – 05/02/2017 Special Election
Voted:x – 11/08/2016 General Election
Voted:R – 03/15/2016 Primary Election
Voted:X – 11/03/2015 General Election
Voted:x – 11/04/2014 General Election
Voted:X – 11/05/2013 General Election
Voted:X – 05/07/2013 Special Election
Voted:x – 11/06/2012 General Election
Voted:R – 03/06/2012 Primary Election
Voted:X – 11/08/2011 General Election

Melissa

As to the despicable campaign literature from the crooks in both political parties, this is so expected. They cannot win without dirty tricks, lies, and covert criminal actions.

Some of the entrenched backroom pols in the local Democrat party need cleaned out.

Gen Murphy uses Mohamed Al-Hamdani’s old law office address. How come? I agree with David there is not a nice bone in Gen’s body, no matter how much she stretches and bends. Gen has her special favorites among the Nan Fans though.
https://www.transparencyusa.org/oh/payee/gen-murphy-associates-llc?cycle=2024-election-cycle

And her mentor, Nan Whaley, well, bags of cash come to mind from FBI probable cause warrants, so there’s that. Now, who was the FBI following – money bag man Willis Blackshear, Senior? Isn’t his Mrs. the Dayton Commission Clerk for Mayor Mims?
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2021/09/08/unsealed-warrants-show-fbi-suspected-dayton-contractor-bribing-mayor-nan-whaley/5767642001/

It makes you want to start a course of study on the money trail of Nan’s PACs and why a county clerk needs a communications director AND a development director. What I see on paper these days are no bid contract / pay to play trails…development money and corporate tax breaks are big business.

Tim Hart

Let’s test Melissa’s Trump derangement ….
Trump is building a $250M ballroom that is privately funded. Obama built a $376M basketball court during a recession, and tax funded. Dems are MAD AF

Last edited 1 month ago by Tim Hart
Tim Hart

Dave, the fact that you use snoops at all is all I need to know you’re relying on that for facts. Good luck.

As for how you feel about January 6, once the facts come out that you don’t know I will accept your apology then.

Melissa

Here’s Tim Hart spouting more conspiracy drivel with so-called facts not yet divulged (they never seem to materialize). I suppose he’s been nipping the Q drops again.

https://d2hxwnssq7ss7g.cloudfront.net/aRWTR7sk7i90_cvt.mp4

https://www.wusa9.com/article/news/national/capitol-riots/i70-paintball-and-airsoft-owner-charged-in-capitol-riots-wearing-qanon-gear-timothy-hart/65-b2582dd8-1272-4dd0-817c-e56829faf180

For your safety, you better get your “papers” for your “heart condition” and keep them close. It makes mask wearing for good health during a Covid pandemic a walk in the park now (for your safety, don’t do that either).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJu0TnoZhHE

Over paid thugs masquerading as actual law-abiding immigration officers are plucking ordinary people off the street and deplaning them into foreign countries. Even lily white law breakers like you, Tim, and unsuspecting little kids in elementary school, and working dads in farm fields, and US citizen veterans with brown skin are getting rounded up. I know. It’s so illegal and wrong, but the Republicans have the bit in their teeth now and are running wild.

Outside of Bob Evans, consult a lawyer when filming for evidence. Don’t call the White House Switchboard because they are not in the office during the whole of government Republican shutdown. Bummer, right?

Spenser

Look out Donald. Esrati only believes in “free speech” if he agrees with it.

Liberals are morons.

The Old Bandito

…how unbecoming, Dear David. Allegations of treason for an event most Americans forgot about on January 7. With his pardon, Tim Hart is as absolved as the Dalit washed in the sacred waters of the Ganga.
I suggest he partake in any and all freedoms allowed, be that voting for Trump, purchasing an AK-47 or procuring a case of top shelf hootch. For he is the recipient of what the Bard said “falleth like the gentle rain from heaven.”
Methinks, Dear David, your moral compass may be in need of a checkup from the neck up. If Tim Hart traveled to New York and murdered an insurance company CEO, you would be authoring him paeans of praise, and posting links to his GoFundMe legal defense fund…

Melissa

FINALLY! Donald said something without invoking his two favorite words.

Ganga is a Hindu goddess who is depicted as a fair, beautiful woman, riding a divine crocodile creature. She is personified as the holy River Ganges where Hindus worship her seeking forgiveness and purification.

You might not know, Old Bandito, but if memory serves Tim got special dispensation from the federal judge to go on a cruise during the time Tim was being prosecuted for his felony criminal actions. Pretty sweet of the federal judiciary, right? It’s nice when the rule of law and equal justice is dispensed without fear or favor.

I hardly think a Trump pardon for Tim Hart and his fellow Jan6 felons compares to the forgiveness and purification from goddess Ganga / River Ganges, but I’m just a mere mortal. I’ll leave that to the gods, goddesses, and other sacred deities of the hereafter to sort out on Resurrection Day. Maybe Tim could take his next cruise up and down the River Ganges for a dip to eternal salvation.

I have to disagree with your assertion, Old Bandito, that Jan6 is a mere memory in the mind of Americans and the world. Provide some evidence of that.

https://webharvest.gov/congress117th/20221231143403/january6report.house.gov/

I know many people who remain outraged to this very day with Trump, the Jan6 insurrectionists, planners, funders, and supporters, for those criminal actions.

https://bsky.app/profile/mjfree.bsky.social/post/3lrftbgmsgk2f

The laws they violated remain on the books. Some pardoned felons are already re-offending, being tried, and jailed. Many were criminals before Jan6 and remain so.

https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/pardoned-jan-6-rioter-charged-threatening-hakeem-jeffries-adding-patte-rcna238891

Melissa

It’s a damn shame Donald Trump is so petty, vain, and vindictive he has weaponized the federal government and further corrupted himself and the Republican Party. He punishes federal employees just for doing their jobs and following the law.

Trump and his criminal sycophants violate the Constitution, federal/state statutes, rules, and ethics on a daily basis. His hires currently serving our government are unfit.

https://bsky.app/profile/iwillnotbesilenced.bsky.social/post/3m4bucaetok2s

Trump is using the power of the presidency for personal gain and he doesn’t care if America and the world sees it because he says he has Article II & SCOTUS immunity.

https://www.reuters.com/investigations/inside-trump-familys-global-crypto-cash-machine-2025-10-28/

Is that truly what America deserves from Trump & the Republicans? NO KINGS says NO.

https://bsky.app/profile/trending.bsky.app/feed/455780072

Donald Trump may need to bathe in the Ganges for the multitude of his sins. India threw off the British yoke and America will do the same with Trump – or go down trying.

Melissa

Don’t be sad, Donald. It’s for your own good and it benefits David’s readers. :)

Maybe you could run to take the helm of the Good Ship Lollipop the next go ’round. A lollipop is best when you can try all the flavors and pick the one you like best.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhns3vwPN0Q

Heck, you could even grow into a big time job like a US diplomat or ambassador!

Donald

Mr Ratty deleted my japes. Leads one to believe he has a thin skin. But by the look of things, Mr Ratty has skin to spare. By the way, Mr Ratty, Congressman Turner, was on national television this week. Your ample skin is green with envy.

Support this site

Use this Amazon link to make purchases and a small percentage of each sale helps fund independent journalism in Dayton.
Amazon

Secret Link