- Esrati - https://esrati.com -

Racism: By the DOJ, the FBI and the State

Let’s compare.

The state of Ohio is revoking two disadvantaged business certifications of a Trotwood trucking company owned by Joyce Sutton Cameron, one of three people indicted on federal charges related to defrauding the city of Dayton’s program for minority and disadvantaged businesses.

The Ohio Department of Administrative Services opened a review of Green Star Trucking on Oct. 30 after federal officials announced the indictment of Sutton Cameron, 71, of Trotwood, her husband and Green Star employee James Cameron, 80, both of Trotwood, and businessman Steve Rauch, 64, of Germantown.

Green Star has been certified as an MBE and EDGE company since 2005, and is also certified by the city of Dayton in the Women Business Enterprise, Dayton Local Small Business Enterprise, and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Section 3 programs. Those certifications give Green Star preference over non-disadvantaged companies on local, state and federally funded projects and helped contractors like Rauch win government contracts that required minority and disadvantaged business participation.

A Dayton Daily News investigation published Sunday found that Rauch used Green Star to meet minority contracting goals for nearly $4.4 million in city of Dayton demolition contracts between 2008 and 2013.

The investigation also found that Green Star won work as a subcontractor on at least 34 public contracts since 2008.

Source: Company’s minority status hits wall – Dayton Daily News [1]

Yet, the Wright State Board of Trustees, David Hopkins and crew burned through $130M and was caught in an H1B visa scandal, and not a single person was charged with a crime.

Difference? The Cameron’s are black. All the people at Wright State are white, with the exception of Nina Joshi and Vishal Soin who are Indian and Michael Bridges who claims to be some kind of minority so his business can be an 8a firm [2] just like Joshi’s and Soins. In the pecking order of “minority businesses” 8a is the write yourself a ticket designation, ranked higher than HUBzone or even Service Disabled Veteran Owned businesses.

But wait, there’s more.

Today the story about the guy who bought the parts of a gun and bullet proof vest for the loser that shot up the Oregon District.

Ethan Kollie pleaded guilty to being an unlawful user of firearms, with a history of using marijuana and psychedelic mushrooms, and lying about his drug use in completing a government form to buy a semi-automatic Romanian-made pistol in May 2019.

A Kettering Fairmont graduate and former Sinclair Community College student, Kollie is the only person to have been charged as a result of the investigation into the Aug. 4 mass killing along East Fifth Street, a shooting spree that left 10 people dead in less than a minute…

Source: Shooter’s friend pleads guilty to 2 gun charges – Dayton Daily News [3]

Ethan Kollie is black. He has spent 15 weeks locked up while waiting to plea.

In the meantime,

Delano Wells, 50, of Trenton has been charged with making false statements on a federal firearms form, according to the U.S. Attorney Southern District of Ohio’s Office.

Source: Butler County man charged with purchasing gun that killed Del Rio [4]

No mention of Wells being held in lockup. His photo isn’t all over the news, but, if you do a search, guess what, he’s White.

Now, let’s go back to minority contracting contracts and preference on contracts.

The author of this site, David Esrati, owns an ad agency in Dayton that is certified by the VA as a “Service Disabled Veteran Owned Business” and also qualifies as a “HUBZone Business” by the SBA. The certifications and letters are posted on his companies website: https://thenextwave.biz/tnw-diversity-certifications/ [5]

When bidding on the Dayton Public Schools marketing contract, that supposedly had a $300K cap, his firm bid under the limit, promised 3.5 man years of work in the bid. The firm had submitted the appropriate certifications to the Dayton Minority business assistance center (the same one that is at the center of the RoShawn Winburn pay to play scandal [6]) and included his qualifications in the bid to DPS.

The agency that “won” the contract bid $345K for 1.5 man years and only claimed they would use a minority subcontractor in their “winning bid.” I requested the bid evaluation sheets- where my firm was libeled and qualifications of my firm were questioned. You can read all of them here: https://esrati.com/schoolmarketing101 [7]

Of course, no investigation. It’s funny how the winner of the DPS bid, The Ohlmann Group [8], also does work for Sinclair, Wright State, CareSource, The PreSchool Promise, the Area Agency on Aging, Montgomery County Business Solutions Center, did the horrid logo for the City of Dayton [9], the list goes on.

Is there an investigation on how one firm seems to have the market cornered on major political donors and governmental bodies? Nope.

There is a different standard in Dayton for those in power and the rest of us. Some can keep filling their pockets with tax dollars and steering contracts to their friends and families, and the rest of us, can keep paying for it.

Who is going to investigate the DOJ and the FBI and the State AG who only seem to be able to indict black people?



If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed [10]! If you wish to support this blog and independent journalism in Dayton, consider donating [11]. All of the effort that goes into writing posts and creating videos comes directly out of my pocket, so any amount helps!
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Plop Star

Also… from the cited article concerning Green Star Trucking: “The decision to revoke came Wednesday after Sutton Cameron failed to provide the state with requested documentation after being informed that the state was reviewing the trucking company’s certifications under the Minority Business Enterprise (MBE) and Encouraging Diversity, Growth and Equity (EDGE) programs, said Melissa Vince, spokeswoman for the Ohio Department of Administrative Services (DAS).” Based on my limited knowledge & understanding (Someone please correct me if I am incorrect): 1. A company was indicted for defrauding programs for minority and disadvantaged businesses in one jurisdiction. 2. As a result of the indictment, the company’s minority and disadvantaged business certifications from another jurisdiction are then placed under review. 3. The company is notified of the review and the certifying body requests documentation from the company. 4. The company does not provide the requested documentation. 5. As a result of not providing the documentation, the certifying body decides to revoke the company’s minority and disadvantaged business certifications. I don’t see racism in this instance. The same thing happens to any company for any certification if they do not provide requested documentation regardless of the race of the owners. I will imagine that someone will point out that only minorities were indicted in the “culture of corruption” investigation (except Steve Rauch of course). If one part of the investigation has been entirely focused on the defrauding of the minority and disadvantaged business programs, who are the primary subjects of this part of the investigation? 1. The people who administer the programs 2. The companies who participate in those programs 3. The people who award contracts based on those programs 4. The companies awarded contracts based on those programs To my knowledge, everyone indicted falls into one of those categories. The charges that individuals face may not be directly related to minority and disadvantaged business programs, but the alleged criminal behavior was discovered because they were investigated as a member of one of those groups. Is it surprising that most of those indicted are minorities? Not really, due to the scope of this part… Read more »

[…] Nan Whaley is white? In both the Toledo and Cincinnati corruption cases against seated officials- only minorities have been charged by the FBI. My very first post on the “Culture of Corruption” April 30, 2019, including my question […]