Republican party HQ on Linden Avenue was packed with people of color, a rare occurrence, I’m guessing, as Republican Party County Chair State Rep Phil Plummer, announces that Mary McDonald and Kate Baker will be the party candidates to take on Debbie Lieberman and Judy Dodge next year for Montgomery County Commission.
McDonald, a lifelong democrat, made the decision after losing her Trotwood Mayorship to the dem party endorsed Yvette Page in a volatile meeting in September [1].
Lieberman has been on the County Commission for almost 20 years, Dodge slightly less. There has never been a Black elected County Commissioner in Montgomery County, although one has been appointed in the past.
The Dem party blamed their un-endorsement of McDonald on her willingness to work with Republicans as she occupied a non-partisan position in a Republican dominated State. McDonald said she worked for the people, as best she could, and was proudest of bringing back a grocery store to Trotwood.
Baker, a Huber Heights Council Woman for Ward 3, was first appointed to the seat when Seth Morgan moved out of Huber Heights in a divorce in 2020. Baker later won the seat in 2021, and would have to vacate it if elected to County Commission.
Lieberman hasn’t faced many formidable challenges in her race, although virtual unknowns have come very close to beating her without too much effort. Her husband, former Montgomery County Dem Party chair, Dennis, was recently soundly defeated in his re-election bid for Clayton Council.
Dodge and Lieberman were frequently seen together like 2 peas in a pod at area restaurants and events- making a questionable quorum if they discussed County business with anyone. They would always blow off any questions of improprieties with “we’re just old friends.”
The last major candidate to switch parties was current County Treasurer John McManus who ran for State Rep against Jim Butler as a D, then turned around and ran for Treasurer as an R.
14 Comments To "McDonald switches parties to challenge Lieberman for County Commission"
#1 Comment By Tim Hart On November 27, 2023 @ 4:43 pm @ 4:43 pm
Funny No one’s ever turning Democrat……. Hummm…..
#2 Comment By Scooter McGee On November 27, 2023 @ 11:05 pm @ 11:05 pm
LOL! McDonald gets the Esrati endorsement of political death. And his old Elmer Fudd lookin’ ass is still lying about why the Dems don’t want anything to do with her. What a pathetic hack. LOL!
Oh well, at least Mary is finally free from living the life of pretending to be a Democrat, and can now be her true self – a religious whack job lie by the minute Republican.
#3 Comment By Pat Offenberger On November 28, 2023 @ 4:13 am @ 4:13 am
Welcome to the Republican party, Ms McDonald! You have my vote.
#4 Comment By Albert J. Belle On November 28, 2023 @ 11:21 am @ 11:21 am
Debbie LIeberman may be one of the lowest IQ ppl to occupy county-wide office.
#5 Comment By jonathan On November 28, 2023 @ 1:25 pm @ 1:25 pm
Your knowledge of local party politics is unlimited, David.
#6 Comment By Hoodie patrol On November 28, 2023 @ 3:19 pm @ 3:19 pm
And now you know why the Democrats didn’t trust her. Just like they don’t trust you.
#7 Comment By David Esrati On November 28, 2023 @ 4:53 pm @ 4:53 pm
To those who think the democratic endorsement means so much-
Clayton Luckie- 2x felony convictions, yet endorsed multiple times.
Joey D Williams- Bribery
Roshawn Winburn- Bribery
Joyce Cameron (preceding Trotwood Mayor) corruption
Nan Whaley and Willis Blackshear Sr.- Feds had open warrants on them both for corruption.
Yet- somehow- I’m not “trustworthy.”
#8 Comment By Hoodie patrol On November 29, 2023 @ 7:27 pm @ 7:27 pm
It’s also because you’re a childish douchebag who holds petty vendettas.
#9 Comment By David Esrati On November 29, 2023 @ 10:17 pm @ 10:17 pm
Better late than never, the Dayton Dayold news gets it 2 days later-
[4]
#10 Comment By Bubba Jones On November 30, 2023 @ 9:06 am @ 9:06 am
You’ve hit the big time, David!! From the Montgomery County Republicans FaceBook page….
Thanks to David Esrati for his coverage of this exciting announcement!
The DDN won’t give you credit, but the GOP will! LOL!!
#11 Comment By Hoodie patrol On December 1, 2023 @ 6:00 pm @ 6:00 pm
Here’s a lil secret – David, like trump, will go with whoever strokes his fragile ego. If that means switching parties, he’s already there.
#12 Comment By Biz On December 1, 2023 @ 6:44 pm @ 6:44 pm
Someone needs to get rid of the Arrested for Debbie “arrested for DUI” Lieberman. This straw woman has been propped up for all the wrong reasons and for far to long.
Didn’t she & hubby have a huge-a$$ IRS lien placed on them for unpaid taxes.
How can these low lives be allowed to govern.
#13 Comment By Casper On September 20, 2024 @ 7:41 am @ 7:41 am
Mr. Esrati, I’m writing to express my deep concern about the allegations that have been made against your recent show pony. Deflating crime statistics in Trotwood? It’s disheartening to hear of such serious accusations. I urge Mr. Plummer to investigate these claims thoroughly and take appropriate action.
Additionally, I’m disappointed in the way you’ve been conducting yourself in the community. Your behavior seems more focused on personal attacks and self-promotion than on addressing the needs of your constituents.
I hope you’ll reconsider your approach and prioritize the well-being of the community you serve.
#14 Comment By David Esrati On September 20, 2024 @ 12:32 pm @ 12:32 pm
@Casper- when you man up and sign your real name- I’ll care what you think. As to “My behavior in the community” – what? Have I been eating kittens and puppies? What you saying Willis?