- Esrati - https://esrati.com -

Board of election reports: 2009 Dayton General Election

As a public service I’m uploading PDFs of the board reports.

The first is the invalid signatures report. 09-appears-invalid-3_10_2009 [1] For Mayor, Larry E. Ealy, James R. Green III and Tojuan W Minus all had insufficient signatures (despite Mr. Ealy turning in the maximum 1500 signatures- apparently, his nominating committee contained people who didn’t live in the city).

For Commission: Donald Allen Domineck Jr., Lorana M Kelly and Mark Anthony Newberry all turned in petitions that were deemed insufficient. Newberry turned in 829 and only had 402.

The second is the appears valid report 09-appears-vaild-3_10_2009 [2].

For Mayor, Rhine McLin and Gary D. Leitzell. For commission, David Esrati, Nannette L Whaley and Joey D. Williams.

For Clerk of Courts- Mark E. Owens running unopposed, for Judge Carl S. Henderson and John S. Pickrel both unopposed.

Interestingly, all signatures were “qualified” in this report- in times past, they stopped counting once they got to 501.

Considering I turned in 641 and had 514 and Judge Pickrel turned in 824 and only had 505, I am very lucky to be on the ballot.

Thank you. I’m looking forward to doing the hard work that I hope you entrust me with.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed [3]! If you wish to support this blog and independent journalism in Dayton, consider donating [4]. All of the effort that goes into writing posts and creating videos comes directly out of my pocket, so any amount helps!
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Congrats Dave, I’m glad you made it! What can I do to help get you elected?

BTW, I saw your picture on the NBC2… did you take that photo of yourself?

Mark Anthony Newberry

A Big Congrats to you David. I’m glad to see that you made it past the BullSh*t that everyone goes through with the petitions. I will support you. Now is the time for you to REACH OUT TO EVERYONE David if you want to win in November.


Call me naive — or perhaps, I just don’t understand the complexity of obtaining signatures of resident registered voters — but, how could someone collect 1500 signatures and over two-thirds be invalid? I suppose that one would have to try very, very hard to do that?

A question – what specifically does “Petition is not in substantial compliance” mean? What specific items does noncompliance on the form refer to? (I assume they’re referring to the Nominating Petition and Statement of Candidacy – Form No. 3-0.)


Thanks for the clarification.

Another question I’ve heard many people ask — why didn’t those individuals who were close to the 500 requirement simply go out and get enough additional valid signatures to put them over that 500 mark?